Writer, editor, stumbler after Jesus


happysadAS SOMEONE WITH a major sweet tooth, I always used to decline chocolate-coated peanuts on the basis that they had a major design flaw: the peanut. After all, take it out, and then you can fill all that space with more chocolate, right? Then I tried one.

Turns out that there’s something better than just sweet―salty and sweet. Somehow the two just seem to accent each other. And, I’m discovering, the same thing can apply to celebrations. Happiness can be heightened with a hint of sadness. Joy may be richer with a splash of grief.

Which is how I have come to think of Thanksgiving slightly differently.

I fell in love with the holiday soon after arriving in the United States more than two decades ago. I was intrigued to learn that people put more effort into getting together with family then than they do at Christmas-time, making it the busiest travel period of the year. While I love the gift-sharing on December 25, I was touched by how people go to so much effort just to be there a month earlier. They make all that effort not for the presents, but just to be present.

I’ve celebrated Thanksgiving in a number of different settings through the years. When the kids were smaller, we had no extended family of our own close by. So, we used to gather various waifs and strays from our church for the day. One year I was even separated from everyone by business travel. So, I shared the holiday with others similarly marooned by our badly-timed fate. As my children have grown, with kids of their own, there have been absences at the table created by the tug of other families.

For some this year there may be empty seats because of divorce, bereavement, addiction, imprisonment, or military service. While you celebrate those who can be there, you also mourn those who can’t or aren’t. My hope for you is that somehow the happiness sweetens the heartache, while the heartache in turn sharpens the happiness.

I’m reminded of when some of the people of Israel were allowed to return from exile to help rebuild the Temple in Jerusalem. When they had laid the new foundation, they gathered to mark the occasion. Ezra 3 records how some of the older people who remembered the former Temple wept, while others―presumably younger folk with no similar memory―shouted for joy.

“As a result, the people could not distinguish the noise of the shout of joy from the noise of the weeping,” Ezra 3:13 says.

Tears and smiles, hugs and empty arms, wistful memories and bright hopes for the future, sweetness and sadness.

Call it Thanksgrieving.

Photo credit: Dermot O’Halloran via Foter.com/CC BY

8 Responses to “Thanksgrieving”

  1. Gene Hulsey

    I know you probably get tired of this—but this is remarkable! Your insight into the most common is extraordinary. Have a blessed Thanksgiving!

    Geni >

  2. johndarnall

    Nicely said Andy. I trust that this year you’ll be unexpectedly surprised by some long forgotten warm and fond memory. Have a blessed time.

  3. Christine M.

    Thanks for that Andy; I didn’t notice that particular bit in my recent reading of Ezra – do you use the same Scripture Union Bible reading notes as I do??

    I hope your Thanksgiving has no more than the necessary amount of grieving.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Basic HTML is allowed. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

%d bloggers like this: